15
Feb
2018

10th Circ. Split Adds Wrinkle To NY Faulty Work Coverage Law

Law360

 Share  print   Print      Download PDF

The Tenth Circuit recently held under New York law that general contractor Black & Veatch Corp.'s liability policy covers damages resulting from a subcontractor's shoddy work, wading into an unsettled area of Empire State jurisprudence and likely setting the stage for the state's highest court to weigh in on the issue.

In a 2-1 opinion issued Tuesday, a panel of the appeals court agreed with B&V that the company's $25 million umbrella policy with Aspen Insurance Ltd. and Lloyd's Syndicate 2003 — collectively referred to as "Aspen" in the decision — applies to claims alleging damage to a third party's property as the result of faulty work by its subcontractor and other lower-tier subcontractors.

The majority predicted that the highest court in New York — whose law governs B&V's policy — would likely follow a "clear trend" among state supreme courts holding that damages tied to a subcontractor's faulty work can constitute an occurrence under a commercial general liability insurance policy. Despite the massive volume of construction projects in New York, the state's high court, known as the Court of Appeals, has yet to issue a definitive ruling on the subject.